I won this YA novel in a contest on Shelf Awareness
(I just love that newsletter). I’ve picked it up several times to start
reading and put it down several times. I could never get past page 40. Yet, there was something compelling about the
story line that kept pulling me back. After reviewing some of the remarks on
Goodreads and Amazon, I was determined to give read this book.
I
didn’t buy the opening car chase scene that involved two teenagers as part of a
larger counterfeiting ring where the police not only pursue them in a
high-speed chase, but actually send a helicopter. Maybe it’s because I’m not a
tween or teen, but to me it didn’t seem plausible.
There
are several things I like about this novel:
- · Strong female protagonist and antagonists.
- · The main plot is bullying and the willingness to combat it.
- · The diversity of the characters.
- · It has GREAT bones.
The
things I didn’t like are:
- · Too many plot lines. The one about Ellis in London should be deleted; it’s irrelevant and confuses the reader. I had to keep going back to figure out what that was going on with those characters. The plot line about the anti-aging drug/terrorism that comes up in the last third is confusing. The counterfeit ring and the bullying are enough.
- · Too many characters that are not truly defined. Yes, Margo and Kat are distinguishable, but the rest all blur together. I can’t remember reading any physical descriptions about the characters that would set them apart.
- · The cover is unappealing.
- · I saw MOB and thought Mafia.
As
I stated earlier, this book has GREAT bones. I think another re-write is in
order if there is a second printing. The ending gives the allusion that this is
the first book in a series. I believe that Smith’s writing will get better as
he or she continues to write.
I
give Mind Over Bullies: A MOB Forms 2
out of 5 stars.
No comments:
Post a Comment